Proportionality of Internal Border Controls: From the Covid-19 Pandemic to the 2021 Proposal

Authors

  • Léa Schumacker Maastricht University

Abstract

Most Schengen Member States reintroduced internal border controls in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. These controls, which in some instances lasted for several months, jeopardised the principle of an area without borders and had to comply with the principle of proportionality. This article examines four aspects of these controls related to proportionality: the type of threat invoked, the adequacy of the measures, the duration of the controls, and the scrutiny over proportionality. First, it demonstrates that the current Schengen Borders Code contains appropriate safeguards for each aspect. However, some Schengen Member States disregarded them during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the Commission did not use its scrutiny powers. In December 2021, the Commission proposed to amend the Schengen Borders Code. This 2021 proposal adapts the rules to the Schengen Member States’ practices during the COVID-19 pandemic. Then, this article argues that this proposal improves the aspects of legal certainty and scrutiny but does not satisfactorily address the aspects of adequacy and duration of internal border controls. In addition, the article presents some recommendations to increase the proportionality of the controls that the Schengen Member States would reintroduce following the 2021 proposal.

Keywords: Schengen Borders Code, proportionality, internal border controls, Covid-19, 2021 proposal, health emergency, NORDIC INFO, scrutiny.

 

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3935/cyelp.18.2022.490

 

Licenca_(2)16.png

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution − Non-Commercial − No Derivatives 4.0 International License.

 

Suggested citation: L Schumacker, ‘Proportionality of Internal Border Controls: From the Covid-19 Pandemic to the 2021 Proposal’ (2022) 18 CYELP 151.

Downloads

Published

2022-12-22

How to Cite

Schumacker, L. (2022). Proportionality of Internal Border Controls: From the Covid-19 Pandemic to the 2021 Proposal. Croatian Yearbook of European Law and Policy, 18, 151−197. Retrieved from https://www.cyelp.com/index.php/cyelp/article/view/490

Issue

Vol. 18 (2022)

Section

Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2022 Léa Schumacker

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

All manuscripts published in CYELP are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution − Non-Commercial − No Derivatives 4.0 International License. This permits anyone to copy and redistribute their work in any medium or format for non-commercial purposes provided the original work and source are appropriately cited.

For all manuscripts published in CYELP, the copyright remains with the author(s). This means that the author(s) grant the right of first publication to the Yearbook, while retaining the copyright to their manuscripts (accepted for publication or published in CYELP), and may republish these, in full or in part, in other publications, books or materials. However, the following conditions should be met:

- the manuscript is published open access;
- when reusing the manuscript, the original source of publication must be properly acknowledged and referenced;
- the manuscript remains published by CYELP on its website;
- the manuscript is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution − Non Commercial − No Derivatives 4.0 International License.